On 31 May 2022 ESMA published a supervisory briefing focused on “Sustainability risks and disclosures in the area of investment management” (link). The briefing is not binding and aims to provide a common supervisory approach for national supervisors. We summarised some of the key topics as well as our views for our clients working in the area of alternative investments.
- For Art. 8 SFDR funds disclosures should only cover “hard, must have” binding characteristics rather than “soft, nice to have” non-binding characteristics
- -> this should limit vague and abstract ESG statements and only allow clearly measurable KPIs, otherwise the binding nature of the characteristic can’t be integrated into an investment decision
- For Art. 9 and 8+ SFDR funds (Art. 8 + sustainable investments) PAI are expected to be considered as part of DNSH for sustainable investments; it is expected to disclose how PAI have been taken into account
- -> the scope of PAI consideration for DNSH purposes is still not clear; ESMA expects at least all mandatory PAIs to be considered for Art. 7 SFDR funds and a conservative assumption could also mean that all mandatory PAI would also have to be considered for funds making sustainable investments;
- -> on the other hand ESMA follows a risk-based approach considering type of assets and the investment strategy; potentially, it could be argued that a lack of certain mandatory PAI may not result into any greenwashing risks or lack of transparency for infrastructure or real estate SPV’s (e.g. how meaningful is it to calculate a gender pay gap for a SPV without employees and how helpful is this information for an infrastructure project investor?)
- Without giving an impression of a “label” to investors, it should be stated under which SFDR and, if relevant, Taxonomy Regulation Article the fund is disclosing information in the fund documentation
- -> rather “aggressive” marketing of Art. 8 / 9 SFDR funds as labels may have to be reduced to a regulatory statement under which Art. the fund discloses information; this is particularly relevant for market participants who are actively promising an Art. 8 / 9 status to investors in their fundraising implying that this status has some implications for the sustainability level of the fund
- The use of green terms such as “ESG”, “green”, “sustainable”, ”social”, “ethical”, “impact” or any other ESG-related terms in funds’ names should be used only when supported in a material way by evidence of sustainability
- -> our understanding is that any “green” term should be supported by a relevant process and ideally a binding KPI helping measuring the outcomes of the process; abstract and or wide reaching statements (e.g. our fund makes the world better) may be hard to defend with objective KPIs
- the use of the term “sustainable” or “sustainability” should be used only by (1) funds disclosing under Article 9 SFDR, (2) funds disclosing under Article 8 SFDR which in part invest in economic activities that contribute to environmental or social objectives and (3) funds disclosing under Article 5 Taxonomy Regulation
- -> based on this exact wording our understanding is that Art. 8 funds without sustainable investments are allowed to use those terms as long as they contribute to E or S objectives;
- -> however, there is a risk that ESMA might have meant Art. 8+ funds only in which case Art. 8 funds without sustainable investments shouldn’t be allowed to use sustainable terms in the name at all
- The use of the word “impact” or “impact investing” or any other impact-related term should be used only by funds whose investments are made with the intention to generate positive, measurable social and environmental impact alongside a financial return;
- -> it is not entirely clear what exactly is meant by “impact”; for instance, the G7 Impact Task Force uses the Impact Management Project (2021) definition of impact: “a change in an aspect of people’s well-being or the condition of the natural environment caused by an organisation “(link); further analysis regarding the impact definition was published by QNG here: QNG-Gastbeitrag_IntelligentInvestors-032022.pdf (fng-siegel.org) ; using the term “impact” might require some recognized reference framework in order to justify it
- ESMA suggests to rely on a non-exhaustive list of sustainability strategies (i.e. best in class, thematic, ESG integration, ESG engagement, impact investing, exclusions).
- -> explicit mentioning one or mutliple strategies from the list may make increase the acceptance by the supervisor; for definitions see, for example the EUROSIF link
- Non-compliance can lead to administrative measures incl. fines and enforcement implemented based on the national laws