On 2 June 2022 ESA’s published Clarifications on the ESAs’ Draft RTS under SFDR . As always, we summarized some key points with regard to alternative investments for our clients below.
PAI vs. DNSH for Sustainable Investments
- Mandatory PAI have to be used for DNSH being part of sustainable investments (Art. 8+, Art. 9 SFDR funds).
- PAI can but don’t have to be used as sustainability indicators to measure the attainment of the E/S characteristics (Art. 8) or sustainable investments (Art. 8+, 9)
- PAI need to be calculated from at least 4 observations (31/3, 30/6, 30/9, 31/12). In ESA’s example an annual (!) PAI value is used and weighed by quarterly holdings value in %:
- In ESA’s example the quarterly PAI value is unknown, therefore an annual PAI value is used assuming that it is equally distributed amongst 12 months. This assumption is very important in practice given that quarterly measures pose significant challenges in practice.
- With regard to holdings values % it is not specified if the equity (NAV) or the enterprise value (GAV) of the company should be taken as a basis. In our view the enterprise value should be used for the sole reason that PAI couldn’t be meaningfully calculated for non-equity instruments otherwise.
- For SPV’s incl. holding companies a look through to the underlying investment could (but doesn’t have to) happen. Where such information is not available, best efforts can be made to obtain the information either directly from investee companies, or by “carrying out additional research, cooperating with third party data providers or external experts or making reasonable assumptions“. For real estate and infrastructure SPV’s this could mean that if it is still necessary to calculate rather meaningless PAI in the context of the specific asset class, this could happen on a best effort basis and with assumptions (see also the BAI Best Practices Guidance – )
- Some additional guidance was published for the calculation methodology of certain PAI.
- “Considering PAI” for Art. 4 SFDR includes publishing a PAI statement with calculated values on the website. This is not the same and separate requirement as “taking PAI into account” for DNSH purposes. When taking PAI into account for DNSH purposes, (i) no publication of a PAI statement is legally required, however ESA’s suggest that a best practice approach could be disclosing PAI values against limits in periodic reports in order to provide evidence that the DNSH criteria are met, (ii) no criteria exist for how exactly to take PAI into account – a possible approach suggested by the ESA’s is to compare PAI values with similar KPI’s defined as limits under the EU Taxonomy, where possible. In any case it seems inevitable to define limits for PAI in order to make the DNSH decision possible.
Taxonomy Alignment
- For fund of funds the calculation of the % Taxonomy alignment in periodic reports of a fund of fund can be done in multiple ways:
- Using the Taxonomy alignment KPIs provided by the target fund (e.g. via EET, via Art. 8/9 periodic reports) -> this will probably be the default option for alternative investments
- Looking through the target fund and obtaining the Taxonomy alignment information from the underlying portfolio companies -> as opposed to a liquid portfolio, this doesn’t sound feasible in practice given that unlisted private companies wouldn’t usually publish such information